"Some See Beetle Attacks on Western Forests as a Natural Event" --NYTimes
"Some See Beetle Attacks on Western Forests as a Natural Event" --by Jim Robbins, NYTimes
Good article to add to the debate about what is "invasive" and what is not, and whether on not human control is possible or desirable. It might make a good PBL in conjunction with the study of fire, or with the study of something that is just spreading or increasing "naturally."
from the article:
"MISSOULA, Mont. — When Ken Salazar — then a senator from Colorado, now secretary of the interior — called the attack on millions of acres of pine forests by the bark beetle the Katrina of the West, he was expressing the common view of the explosive growth of the beetles as an unmitigated disaster.
But not everybody sees it that way. Some environmentalists and scientists support the beetles. While they acknowledge the severity of the problems the beetles are causing, they argue that the insects, which kill only mature trees larger than five inches in diameter, are a natural phenomenon, like forest fires, and play a vital ecological role.
“It’s not the end of the forests, and they are not destroyed,” said Diana L. Six, a professor of forest entomology and pathology at the University of Montana here, who has studied the beetle for 16 years, as she walked in a beetle-infected forest near here recently .
“Lodge pole pine evolved to go out with a stand-replacing event, such as fire or beetles, then regenerate really quickly,” she said. “When they hit 80 or 90 years of age all of a sudden the beetles become a player — the trees are big enough for the beetles to attack. They reset the clock on the stand.”
Dr. Gregg DeNitto, a forest health specialist with the Forest Service here, said the beetles were not “an exotic like the emerald ash bore.”
“This is a native insect in a native host, and these are normal biological processes that have happened for millennia,” Dr. DeNitto said.
Nothing can or should be done to halt the spread of the beetle, experts say..."
Good article to add to the debate about what is "invasive" and what is not, and whether on not human control is possible or desirable. It might make a good PBL in conjunction with the study of fire, or with the study of something that is just spreading or increasing "naturally."
from the article:
"MISSOULA, Mont. — When Ken Salazar — then a senator from Colorado, now secretary of the interior — called the attack on millions of acres of pine forests by the bark beetle the Katrina of the West, he was expressing the common view of the explosive growth of the beetles as an unmitigated disaster.
But not everybody sees it that way. Some environmentalists and scientists support the beetles. While they acknowledge the severity of the problems the beetles are causing, they argue that the insects, which kill only mature trees larger than five inches in diameter, are a natural phenomenon, like forest fires, and play a vital ecological role.
“It’s not the end of the forests, and they are not destroyed,” said Diana L. Six, a professor of forest entomology and pathology at the University of Montana here, who has studied the beetle for 16 years, as she walked in a beetle-infected forest near here recently .
“Lodge pole pine evolved to go out with a stand-replacing event, such as fire or beetles, then regenerate really quickly,” she said. “When they hit 80 or 90 years of age all of a sudden the beetles become a player — the trees are big enough for the beetles to attack. They reset the clock on the stand.”
Dr. Gregg DeNitto, a forest health specialist with the Forest Service here, said the beetles were not “an exotic like the emerald ash bore.”
“This is a native insect in a native host, and these are normal biological processes that have happened for millennia,” Dr. DeNitto said.
Nothing can or should be done to halt the spread of the beetle, experts say..."
Tags: forests, invasives, landuse, management
About
Fireside Council
Questions, problems, comments? Here is the "Fireside Council" of folks who help Connie with the administration of this site: Anna, Ian, Mike, and Or-Tal. Click on their names to visit their Profile Pages and leave comments for them with your inquiries and ideas! Meanwhile, if you have technical questions or suggestions, Laura will be glad to help.
Roll The Dice
Roll the dice... and visit a random Fireside member production online!
Roll The Dice
Roll the dice... and visit a random Fireside member production online!
(It's easy to make your own Delicious dice if you want!)
Delicious Firesidelearning
© 2009 Created by Connie Weber on Ning. Create a Ning Network!
